Supplement brand · identity withheld
Completed case
Before
4.2
4-star display
increased to
After
4.4
4½-star display range
- Reviews removed
- 2
- Case duration
- 11 days
Bad reviews are selling your competitors' products.
We challenge the ones that break Amazon's rules.
We find the policy issue, build the appeal, and track Amazon's decision. You only pay after a removal is verified.
- Reviews removed
- 7,549
- Brands monitored
- 2,300+
Every day a rule-breaking review stays live, another shopper reads it and picks the next listing.
Amazon makes the final call. If it stays up, there is no success fee.
Example case
Appeal in progressDailyRise Greens Gummies
B0G7K2M9Q4 · Amazon.com
“These taste like wet grass. The seller is a scam, their support people are thieves, and anyone buying this is an idiot.”
Why it moved
0/4- Waiting
Detected
Seller attack + buyer insult
- Waiting
Cited
Harassment and seller conduct
- Waiting
Filed
Appeal and review quote submitted
- Waiting
Removed
Live listing rechecked
Verified outcome
Checking live listingBefore
4.2 rating
Target
4½-star display range
Listing rating 4.2 → target 4.3
A stronger first impression where shoppers make the decision.
A bad review can keep you under the star buyers actually choose.
Shoppers see the stars, skim the worst objection, and decide if the product feels safe to buy. Set your current rating to see the next step worth reaching.
What is your product at?
4.2
4.0-star example
Next milestone
4.3 · 4½ stars
3.5 minimum5.0
Build toward the 4½-star range
The most important near-term display goal for many established listings.
One removed 1-star≈ 4 new 5-star ratings
Simple-average comparison. Amazon weights ratings; targets are directional, not guaranteed.
One believable bad review can do damage every day.
"The flavor is awful. The seller is a scam, their support team are thieves, and anyone buying this is an idiot."
The taste opinion stays. Seller attacks and buyer harassment may qualify for a policy-based appeal. We separate the two.
Find the reviews that break the rules. Challenge those. Reach the next star step. Defend the rating you've earned.
Legitimate product criticism stays. We only build cases around specific policy issues.
We do the work. You keep the revenue.
We find the policy issue, prepare the evidence, file the appeal, and verify Amazon's decision. No removal means no success fee.
Step 01·DETECTED·After import
We inspect the reviews Amazon makes available.
Paste a listing. We read the available reviews and flag the ones that may break Amazon’s written policies.
Example review
“The box arrived crushed and the driver left it in the rain.”
Packaging and delivery · not product performance
$0No card required.
Step 02·CITED·After analysis
We cite the exact rule each one breaks.
Each candidate is tied to a specific policy clause. Unsupported reviews are left alone and do not become cases.
Product reviews cannot focus only on the seller, order, shipping, packaging, condition, or delivery experience.
$0Still nothing charged.
Step 03·FILED·After approval
We build the case. You approve. We file it.
A trained specialist reviews every case. You approve the evidence and filing settings; nothing is auto-submitted.
Appeal draft · 3 citationsFiled through Amazon's official report flow
$0You approve before we send.
Step 04·REMOVED·After Amazon acts
A verified removal closes the case. Then you pay.
Amazon decides. If the review disappears, we verify the outcome before billing. If Amazon declines, there is no success fee.
“The box arrived crushed and the driver left it in the rain.”
Removed
Verified against the live listing before any success fee bills.
$299Per removed review. Or $99 on Scale.
Verified customer result
Two removals moved this listing into the 4½-star range.
An authorized, anonymized result from a supplement brand. Amazon made the removal decisions; Review Magic verified the outcome.
Verified
Pay for removals. Not promises.
Choose one-off pricing or a plan with lower removal rates. If a review stays up, there is no success fee.
Make us earn month two.
New to Review Magic? Add a card and start for $0 today. Your first verified removal in the first 30 days is free; additional removals use the plan's published success fee. Subscription billing begins after day 30—cancel before then and you won't be charged for the subscription. Available once per customer.
No commitment
Pay Per Removal
One-off cleanup with no commitment.
$299/removal
No subscription · pay only on success
No monthly fee, no contract
Billed only on a successful removal
10 products monitored
1 Amazon account
Or subscribe for ongoing protection
Annual: 12 paid months for the price of 10.
Swipe to compare ›
No commitment
One-off cleanup, success fee only.
Pay Per Removal
One-off cleanup with no commitment.
$299/removal
No subscription · pay only on success
No monthly fee, no contract
Billed only on a successful removal
10 products monitored
1 Amazon account
Three ongoing subscriptions
Annual: 12 paid months for the price of 10.
Starter
Always-on monitoring for a small catalog.
$149/month
$0 today · billing starts after 30 days
1 removal included/mo
First verified removal free during trial
$149 per extra removal
50 products monitored
1 Amazon account
Best value
Growth
Best for most brands with steady review volume.
$499/month
$0 today · billing starts after 30 days
3 removals included/mo
First verified removal free during trial
$129 per extra removal
500 products monitored
2 Amazon accounts
Scale
Large catalogs and agency portfolios.
$1,500/month
$0 today · billing starts after 30 days
6 removals included/mo
First verified removal free during trial
$99 per extra removal
10,000 products monitored
50 Amazon accounts
Every subscription includes
Unused removal credits roll over. Monitoring, evidence gathering, appeal preparation, and verified case history stay in one account.
Common questions.
Straight answers about appeals, access, timing, and fees.
We file through Amazon's own report flow — the same button Amazon puts on every review — and cite their written policies. No incentives, no buyer contact, no review manipulation. The full methodology is on our Compliance page.
See which reviews are worth challenging.
Paste a product link or ASIN. We'll show you the strongest policy cases before you create an account.
Don't have a product ready? ·Create an account
Free preview · No card · No success fee if nothing is removed